Thursday, November 22, 2012

Interview process should be systematic

Q. I am the VP of business development for a growing IT and telecom company. We are in the process of interviewing candidates for a business development manager position. Our applicants come from various sources: online ads, internal employees and referrals. To date we have not had a successful interview process, any tips?

A. The last few columns I recommended that each and every applicant who applies for a position complete a pre-qualification questionnaire and be telephone interviewed before you extend an invitation for an on-site interview. I’m assuming that you’ve gone through this process and have chosen candidates to meet with your selection team based off of your “best-fit” profile for the position and company. 

What is a selection team? It is a group of interviewers who are knowledgeable about your company’s history and milestones, plans for growth, products, services, strengths, challenges and have a strong understanding of the best fit for the position and company. Each and every person on your selection team should be coached on interviewing techniques (do’s and don’ts), work from a list of pre-approved interview questions and take detailed notes. 

Why? If the selection team is asking random questions it will be difficult to assess the candidate’s fit for the position. If the selection team is asking inappropriate questions you could be opening yourself up to legal issues.

I recommend a post-interview meeting. This is an opportunity to debrief with the selection team and evaluate the positive and negative qualities about the candidates and assess who is the best fit.

How long should the interview last? Thirty to 60 minutes per interview is sufficient time. It is important to stay on schedule – time is valuable. How many people should be involved in the interview? It depends on your organization. Some companies, due to their size and operation, prefer one person from each department. If you are a large company this could turn into an all-day interview. If you’re a small company the key decision makers are the best choice.

You mentioned that some of your applicants are internal employees. This can be tricky. It is important that all applicants go through the same process. Keep it formal, no special favors or cutting corners for this critical step. If this person is not selected for the position it is important that this be handled delicately. Help this person understand why they were not selected for the position and how they can improve their skills.

The best and worst hires can be promotions from within. Why? Because internal candidates sometimes feel a sense of entitlement – they’ve been with the company for a period of time and believe that they are the best person for the job even though they lack the experience. Hiring managers can feel obligated to promote internal employees because of their time with the company and friendships developed on and off the job, but the employee may lack the skills to make a difference in the role.

Here is a list of the most popular interview questions. If you’re planning for a 30-minute interview, pick five questions to ask, and if you’re planning for a 60-minute interview choose 10. It is helpful to communicate to candidates that you have planned for a certain amount of time and have approximately five to 10 minutes per question. It’s important for all interviewers to learn how to command the interview.

1. Tell me about yourself. (This is a good warm-up question that helps people open up and talk about themselves. You can learn a lot about someone from just this one question.)

2. What do you know about our company? (What you’re looking for here is their knowledge of the company’s history, goals, products, services, ideal clients, management team and philosophy. Have they done their homework?)

3. Why did you leave your last position? Tell me about your past relationships with co-workers and supervisors. (Are they committed to your industry and this type of position? How do they communicate about their former employers or managers? Look for patterns; everyone has a story. )

4. What are your strengths? (Look for someone who can communicate their positive attributes related to the position backed up by examples minus an inflated ego.)

5. Areas for improvement? (Every one has one or two, beware of candidates who say they have none.)

6. Give an example of your greatest accomplishment and biggest failure. (Best fit are people who have experienced success and failure and understand the causes.)

7. How do you handle pressure and stress? (Ask for examples when they were under extreme pressure or stress and how they handled the situation.)

8. What is most important to you in your job? (What are their priorities: money, benefits, flexibility, career development, solving problems, helping others, challenges?)

9. Why do you want to work for us? (What is their level of interest and motivation in working for your organization?)

10. Why should I hire you? (Are they confident about themselves and able to showcase their selling points?)

Always end the interview on a positive note. Why? Because you are the face of the company, and it is crucial that this person walks away feeling positive about their experience.
We live in a world of social networking, and people are talking about their experiences – positive and negative. What do you want people to say about you and your company?

No comments:

Post a Comment